What Are the Best Subway Subs According to Reddit Users?
When it comes to fast food sandwich chains, Subway Menu UK remains one of the most popular options worldwide. With its vast selection of meats, cheeses, vegetables, and sauces, Subway gives customers the freedom to create their ideal sub. But with so many choices available, it can be hard to decide what to order. That’s where Reddit comes in.
The online forum is full of food enthusiasts who aren’t shy about sharing their honest opinions. Whether you're a Subway regular or a first-timer looking for the perfect sub, Reddit users have plenty of advice to offer. We combed through hundreds of Reddit threads, comments, and votes to uncover the best Subway subs according to the people who know them best—the customers themselves.
Here are the top subs Reddit users swear by, along with their reasons and personal tweaks.
1. The Italian B.M.T. – A Classic Favorite
Why Reddit Loves It:
The Italian B.M.T. consistently ranks as one of the best-loved sandwiches on Reddit. Many users describe it as the go-to option for meat lovers, featuring pepperoni, salami, and ham.
One Redditor wrote:
“It’s got just the right balance of salty meats. Toasted with provolone, plus veggies and a bit of chipotle southwest sauce—perfection.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Italian Herb & Cheese
-
Cheese: Provolone or Pepper Jack
-
Toasted: Always
-
Veggies: Lettuce, tomato, onions, banana peppers
-
Sauce: Chipotle Southwest or mayonnaise
2. Chicken Bacon Ranch – Creamy and Satisfying
Why Reddit Loves It:
If you’re looking for something hearty and indulgent, Chicken Bacon Ranch is often suggested. The mix of grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch dressing creates a flavorful combo that hits all the right spots.
One user said:
“This is my cheat-day sandwich. It’s greasy, cheesy, and amazing when toasted. Add jalapeños for a spicy twist.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Italian or Flatbread
-
Cheese: Monterey Cheddar
-
Veggies: Lettuce, cucumbers, green peppers
-
Extra: Toast it with the bacon and cheese to melt everything together
-
Sauce: Ranch + a touch of Chipotle Southwest
3. Steak & Cheese – A Crowd-Pleaser
Why Reddit Loves It:
Many Reddit users call the Steak & Cheese Subway’s answer to the Philly cheesesteak. The key, they say, is getting it toasted with double cheese.
According to a Redditor:
“You can’t go wrong with steak and cheese. Load it up with green peppers and onions, and toast it so the cheese melts into the meat.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: White or Italian Herb & Cheese
-
Cheese: Double American or Swiss
-
Veggies: Onions, green peppers, jalapeños
-
Sauce: Garlic aioli or Chipotle Southwest
-
Pro tip: Ask for extra meat if you’re really hungry
4. Spicy Italian – Bold and Zesty
Why Reddit Loves It:
Reddit users who love spicy flavors often go for the Spicy Italian, which includes pepperoni and salami. It's a simple but bold choice, with fans saying the key is to pair it with the right veggies and sauces.
One comment read:
“Spicy Italian toasted with pepper jack, pickles, banana peppers, and chipotle sauce. It’s the perfect spicy combo.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Jalapeño Cheese (if available)
-
Cheese: Pepper Jack
-
Veggies: Pickles, banana peppers, jalapeños
-
Sauce: Chipotle Southwest or hot sauce
5. Turkey Breast – Lean and Versatile
Why Reddit Loves It:
For those seeking a lighter or healthier option, Turkey Breast often comes up as the best pick. It’s low in fat and high in protein, making it ideal for clean eaters.
One Reddit user said:
“Turkey breast on wheat with a bunch of veggies is my go-to for a guilt-free lunch. Add a little mustard for flavor.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: 9-Grain Wheat
-
Cheese: Swiss or no cheese
-
Veggies: Load up with lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, spinach
-
Sauce: Honey mustard or plain yellow mustard
6. Meatball Marinara – Comfort Food in a Sub
Why Reddit Loves It:
When you want something hot and comforting, Reddit says Meatball Marinara is the answer. It’s messy, cheesy, and rich.
One user posted:
“The marinara soaks into the bread just right. Extra mozzarella and parmesan make it even better.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Italian
-
Cheese: Mozzarella or Shredded Monterey
-
Toasted: Always
-
Extras: Add parmesan and black pepper for a pizza-like taste
7. Tuna – Surprisingly Popular
Why Reddit Loves It:
Though it might surprise some, Tuna subs have a loyal fanbase on Reddit. The creamy mixture pairs well with fresh veggies.
One comment said:
“I always get tuna with onions, pickles, and a splash of vinegar. It sounds weird, but it’s amazing.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Wheat or Flatbread
-
Cheese: Cheddar
-
Veggies: Pickles, red onions, cucumbers
-
Sauce: Oil & vinegar or no extra sauce
8. Veggie Delight – The Plant-Based Winner
Why Reddit Loves It:
Vegetarians (and even meat-eaters) rave about the Veggie Delight. It’s affordable, customizable, and surprisingly filling.
A top Reddit comment said:
“It’s what you make of it. Add every veggie, get extra cheese, and throw on all the sauces you love.”
How to Customize:
-
Bread: Multigrain or Flatbread
-
Cheese: All 3 if you’re feeling wild
-
Veggies: Everything – don’t hold back
-
Sauce: Sweet onion, chipotle, and ranch combo
Reddit Tips for the Best Subway Experience
Beyond favorite subs, Reddit users share a few bonus tips:
-
Always Toast It
Most subs taste better toasted. It melts the cheese and crisps the bread just right. -
Double the Cheese or Meat for Flavor
For a small extra charge, you can significantly upgrade your sandwich. -
Don’t Skip the Sauces
Sauces make or break a sub. Mix and match to find your perfect flavor. -
Ask for Extra Veggies
Subway doesn’t usually charge for more vegetables—load them up! -
Try it as a Wrap
For a lower-carb option, turn your favorite sub into a protein bowl or wrap.
Final Thoughts
If you ever find yourself staring at the Subway menu, overwhelmed by choices, remember: Reddit has your back. From the spicy kick of the Spicy Italian to the indulgent layers of the Chicken Bacon Ranch, there’s something for everyone. Whether you're health-conscious, meat-obsessed, or plant-based, these top Reddit-recommended Subway subs are a great starting point for your next order.
